I love surprises. Spooky and Rusty were surprise eggs, actually.
We've been having a disagreement about their father's gender. It didn't help that in addition to Buffy's pink eggs, I had also gotten some terra cotta colored ones. Until recently, the only candidate for laying those was Buffy (still, because LRH hadn't quit the field until a couple of days ago). Anyway, BD kept saying they were Red's eggs.
On my first hatch, darned if all the little terra cotta eggs didn't hatch into little red chicks, prolonging the argument. I said Red was the father of the red ones. Well...Spooky and Rusty are siblings, both from terracotta eggs. Buffy must have laid that other color prior to the pink eggs she lays now.