Well okay!
I'm done for the year. My main goal now is to make sure this idiot doesn't get any of my deer. Hopefully me and the dog going out there will keep them away today.
Your quote above makes no sense--- game animals belong to no one. You can't claim them as yours. Regardless of skill level, if the idiot is legally licensed, following the rules of law, he is making a legal hunt.
Secondly in your original post you talk about taking 2 deer- one which dropped in it's tracks- the other was taken/stolen by some one else who claimed he shot it. So the second deer shot evidently did not drop like a rock, it must have been wounded and managed to cover some ground before it succumbed to it's wounds. If I read correctly, this is one of the problems you have with the idiot. Being a "hunter" myself, I know that of all fatal shots, very very very few are instantly fatal. On a deer sized target pulling a shot by 6" or less can be all the difference, very very very few of us can claim 100% accuracy.
What I know for a fact-- they ain't no hunter in the world that hasn't miffed a shot atleast once (or twice or ten times)-- including myself. Sure some people who claim to be hunters are nothing more than misguided individuals wondering about in the woods WITH GUNS, others are unlucky- and others are the true 10% whose skill level far exceeds the average Joe.