Quote:
First, I'm assuming this is a perpetual awards system, and not limited to a specific number of awards per category.
Would it be difficult to make a third "Nomination" button, in addition to the Report and Quote buttons? Once hitting the nomination button, there would be a drop-down menu (just like the report button has) which lists the various awards possible (to keep peeps from making them up as they go), and a comment box.
Then, before an award can be made, the nominee must have accumulated a certain number of nominations (maybe 5? - 10? - 15?) for the same category (must from different peeps). And maybe the nominations must include some sort of commentary, which might help exclude the popularity votes. I would also think the nominee should be an active BYC member in good standing for at least a year.
Once a member accumulates the prerequiste nominations, then staff can validate the nominations and member eligilibility.
It might be nice, then, to distribute the awards just once a month, and make a really nice staff announcement of the monthly awards.
Of course, any nominations a member receives would carryforward if they haven't reached 10 in a particular month. Maybe you can use a cutoff date of the 25th of every month to close nominations for that month, use the next 5 days for validations, and make the monthly awards at month-end.
Again, just thinking out loud here with some ideas. I have no idea if 10 nominations is too low, too high, or just right, in this scenario.