Love love love all the ideas.. Happy news is that I caught him!!!!!!!!! I wanted him gone TODAY... too impatient to wait until night, and then I would have to probably get pecked. He's so ornery, if I try to pet him while roosting he pecks my hand.. Anyway, I cornered him, and basically caught him in a storage bin. I then put the lid on it, and BUCKLED it shut (found some crazy buckle belt thing in my husband's shop) so he couldn't pop the lid.
My neighbors took him and THANKED me. Oh my.... He was thrown in a pen instantly with many other chickens. I can't help but feel sorry for him, but maybe he'll get to live at least (for awhile anyway) ???
Now, I have moved my "babies" into the coop... so no more chasing them around at night when it's time for them to go in the "medium-brooder".. I'm so so happy! I will miss his crowing.. however I have no shortage on roosters. Three of my four babies are roosters and crowing now too (just very amateurely)