I'm not private, I had 13 people in my room during my entire labor including my father, so I can't relate... BUT when it comes to childbirth, Weddings and a few other events in life I am a firm believer you have a right to demand anything, everything and be as picky or odd as you want. I couldn't agree with you more, my baby is only 3 months so I vividly remember her birth right now and the things that help you deal with the pain are strange sometimes, the things that make the pain even worse can also be very small things or odd things. you have every right to ask that noone be there at all, and I'm sorry but hubs doesn't have to go through what you're going through, if he can't respect, support and sympathize with your needs/decision then too bad 
