after seeing these pictures i am starting to think my wellie flock is not as bad as i thought i was realy disappointed with my egg color but mine lay three on one off three on ond take a day or two break and start again i am wanting to get mine to lay five to seven on color chart and i have seen some pictures that convince me this is possible is anyone else working to improve egg color? if so i would love to hear from you! my darkest layer lays a three to four on her first day and never drops below a three my others lay light twos but with lots of speckles if i breed only the darkest layer will i have the chance of getting darker than what she is laying or is this the darkest i can expect from her offspring?
I would just like to clarify, the pictures of birds you have seen on this thread lately, for the most part, aren't anywhere near SOP. Egg color is a strong component of the breed, but a mutt chicken can lay a dark egg too, so egg color does not equate quality Welsummers. Now, if you only are concerned about a dark egg, ignore the rest of this post.
The experts on here don't critique a bird unless someone has specifically asked them to and when they do on this site they tend to be very gentle in their feedback. If a bird is really bad they often refrain from saying much at all. I'm not trying to discourage you, I just want you to have a more realistic perspective when comparing your birds. For example, if you compare the hen in this post
https://www.backyardchickens.com/t/271757/the-welsummer-thread/9300#post_12664819
to other hens pictured more frequently on this thread you will see a huge difference. The birds in the post are more even in color. Their backs are the correct flat - no raised cushioned area on the back and no curve to them. They are very proportionate in shape and their legs are deep yellow. Most hens you see on this thread have heavy peppering (too much black) on their back, they are not proportionate, their tail angles are too low, the legs are not bright yellow and the hackle coloration is very uneven. Its even rarer to see a good rooster - wing carriage is too low on most, back are not flat at all, they are not proportionate, have pale legs and many have white fluff at the base of the tail. Newer breeders tend to look at the comb first and say "oh the comb is even, that's a good rooster", but this is a minor issue compared to the overall bird.
the WCNA members try to walk a fine line as we want to encourage people to learn about the breed and its very easy to get discouraged if someone really picks apart a bird. If you really want to learn about the breed I would suggest joining the WCNA, but also make a point of finding GOOD examples of the breed.