Zanna
Songster
Not a bad rooster, and the black in the lower hackle feathers is not a fault (cf. the SOP) although I once saw a judge's comment marking it as a fault. Leg color is great, overall plumage color looks good, and the mottling of brown in the breast backwards is good. Concerns: Comb a bit large, especially growing too far over the beak; backline could be a bit more level (hard to tell, though, from the picture); and the tail angle is too low for our SOP and also the Dutch/UK standard (probably correct'for the German/Scandinavian standard) [the UK and Dutch standards state "high tail carriage" --ours states 60 degrees. You may have hens that should be a good match.
Thank you very much for the detailed critique, very helpful! I will have to watch him tomorrow from outside the pen instead of inside, crouched on the ground, with him trying to get away from me. I think his normal tail carriage is higher than it looked in the pics. My hens all have quite small combs so we shall try some test matings and see what we get. I may also take him to a show in Stevenson, WA in April and see what the judges think if enough of you think he is worthy.