I understand your desire to just have some mature hens laying eggs. I feel that way too, and definitely easier! Roosters, IMO, will have a 'alpha'. if you have two who want to be top dog, they fight bloodily. I have culled all my nasty roosters over the past many years and chosen breeds who are known to be personable (welsumer, Wyandotte). So far, so good with the new hatches. I propose that Dads more calm behavior does trickle down the genetic line! A good roo is hard to find, but hes out there. make sure your roosters let you pick them up without biting you, or jumping at you, etc. You want a rooster who knows that You are the alpha!
I want a good rooster at some point, so I'm not raising chicks anymore. (I don't actually like raising chicks.) If I can keep both long term that would be great, but even if I have to choose between them, I wont be able to make that choice until they are roosters. Some people have had good luck with a bachelor pad, allowing conjugal visits with the hens from time to time for fertilized eggs. I'm exploring that idea too.