Any Home Bakers Here?

I found the dough "should be just right" NOT too Wet....NOT to Dry. You should be
able to handle ANY Dough. After you Bake Breads you get to know the
"Wetness or Dryness" of the Correct Dough. At the Final Shape...the dough should NOT stick to your hands. If too wet...It WILL NOT HOLD it's shape.
That about sums it up! I ended up having to add flour to get it to let go of my hands and form any sort of shape. I probably killed it trying to get it to that point. I guess I have to figure out how "wet" is needs to be before the first fold rather than after the last rise?

My Mom said add flour until the dough feels right. Not to helpful but true!
Yep, do "x" until it looks or feels right. Easier to do when you know what "right" is and how to get there.

Texture is OK, has holes, really flat.
DSCN2010.JPG
 
That about sums it up! I ended up having to add flour to get it to let go of my hands and form any sort of shape. I probably killed it trying to get it to that point. I guess I have to figure out how "wet" is needs to be before the first fold rather than after the last rise?


Yep, do "x" until it looks or feels right. Easier to do when you know what "right" is and how to get there.

Texture is OK, has holes, really flat.
View attachment 2197554
Mine was like that too. I assume we need to keep making it and develop the feel for it. I was also wondering if a new starter maybe doesn’t have enough oomph. Even with added yeast, which I did too. I heard mention of adding vital wheat gluten, I bought some but haven’t used it yet. I have ap flour, so maybe higher protein bread flour would add some loft. So many factors to consider!
 
Something you already have learned: Making Sourdough Bread is an
Art ... a Science .... and takes PRACTICE. "Progress not Perfection" Aria
Yes it sure does! But my practicing with this is resulting in both of us eating much more bread than we ever did before! I need to take up raw vegetable carving or something! :gig
 
Yes it sure does! But my practicing with this is resulting in both of us eating much more bread than we ever did before! I need to take up raw vegetable carving or something! :gig
If you are not having success .... perhaps you want to try Sandwich
Sourdough Bread....there are many recipes in the index. And it is
easier. Consideration? Or Practice Not Perfection...your choice. Aria
 
If you are not having success .... perhaps you want to try Sandwich
Sourdough Bread....there are many recipes in the index. And it is
easier. Consideration? Or Practice Not Perfection...your choice. Aria
Absolutely right, at least in my case. I have had no real problem making the King Arthur basic sourdough loaf. The first didn't rise quite enough, the second too much (and the only problem with too much was the "muffin top", made it hard to get out of the glass pan), the last 2 were just right. Gives me hope that I can manage these "artisan" types, not sure why they are causing me so much trouble. I'm really thinking about hitting a KA baking class when they open back up if they have one for artisan sourdough.
 
That about sums it up! I ended up having to add flour to get it to let go of my hands and form any sort of shape. I probably killed it trying to get it to that point. I guess I have to figure out how "wet" is needs to be before the first fold rather than after the last rise?


Yep, do "x" until it looks or feels right. Easier to do when you know what "right" is and how to get there.

Texture is OK, has holes, really flat.
View attachment 2197554
If the starter stays at the same hydration, try adding 64G of bread flour.
 
Absolutely right, at least in my case. I have had no real problem making the King Arthur basic sourdough loaf. The first didn't rise quite enough, the second too much (and the only problem with too much was the "muffin top", made it hard to get out of the glass pan), the last 2 were just right. Gives me hope that I can manage these "artisan" types, not sure why they are causing me so much trouble. I'm really thinking about hitting a KA baking class when they open back up if they have one for artisan sourdough.

I always thought those looked like some good classes. If you get the chance to attend, hope you'll bring back some tips for us.
 
Debby, What is a good kitchen scale to measure grams? I have two
Kitchen Scales always out in my kitchen next to my Hoosier. But I do
not have a gram scale. I Google the grams and they give me the answers.
Aria

@Aria

I have a Hamilton Beach Scale. It will do all the weights. It has a button on the bottom to toggle between the different types of weight.

It is approximately 6 to 8 inches by 3.5 to 4 inches by 0.5 inches. Very easy to store.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom