GENDER?! 1 WEEK LATER... the debate continues !!

[GermanKennhuhn]

1 is a cockerel, and 2 is a pullet - they are Easter Eggers.

I agree!

 

[TheOddOneOut]

Both are female. My foot goes down.

 

[Buckwheat77]

Both are female. My foot goes down.

@TheOddOneOut - I’m new to this so I didn’t know how to tag someone until now - thank you to the person who did! I was hoping I’d see a comment from you following last week’s discussion!!
Crossing my fingers you’re right !

 

[SBFChickenGirl]

2 is definitely a pullet. 1.... I don't see any red on the shoulders (a male trait).... but that tail! I'm leaning towards cockerel like @sourland