GENDER?! 1 WEEK LATER... the debate continues !!

[Buckwheat77]

Hello everyone! About a week ago I posted some pics of my Americaunas ! There was quite the discussion if they were boys or girls. Everyone I consult still has mixed reviews !!!
Sorry to post again, but hoping a week has made some difference and I got some better pictures !!
They are 12 weeks/3 months old in these pictures. I labeled them 1 and 2 to help tell who’s who (1- Sven... 2 - Chip). Both our RIR are boys and we are hoping to have at least one girl. My partner and I both have families with 3 boys and 1 girl so I guess it’s meant to be !!

 

[sourland]

1 is a cockerel, and 2 is a pullet - they are Easter Eggers.

 

[Buckwheat77]

1 is a cockerel, and 2 is a pullet - they are Easter Eggers.

Thank you !! How can you tel they are EEs? I had a feeling they were !!

 

[sourland]

Coloring is not correct for any of the recognized Ameraucana varieties.

 

[Chickenhappy8708]

Americana=EE. My 15 week OE pullet also has a pea comb, so I'm not sure about 2 either... Because mines is barely pink. But I trust @sourland has more experience than me, and I'm bad at EEs.... So here is mine, I have no clue on yours.

 

[Mamatomany123]

I think they're both male. Heres my pullet easter eggers at 12 weeks. They were still very pale.

 

[Buckwheat77]

I can’t help but laugh!! The discussion continues. I really appreciate all the info and opinions - these are my first chickens !!! Please keep them coming thank you everyone !!

 

[Buffbrahmasforever]

Combs are not overly red or bright pink. There are no red patches of feathers on wings. They both have a pullet like stance. Number two has a similar pattern to both my old past EE hen and my cousins new EE pullet. I don't see any emerging male specific feathering. I say pullets but I might be wrong.

 

[BuckeyeAmy69]

I’m seeing 2 pullets. Those are both pullet combs and tails. https://www.backyardchickens.com/ar...ail-feathers-in-easter-egger-juveniles.75908/

 

[The Happster]

Both are pullets.

@Overo Mare, @TheOddOneOut