Hi everyone! I hope I'm not interrupting this convo in a rude way, but I figured this would be the correct thread for a question about this breed.
We currently have a mixed flock of 3 that we are looking to add to. I would like a dark egg layer that lays fairly consistently with good attitude and not too broody.
We live in a residential neighborhood, so no screamers aloud as to not annoy the neighbors. Clucking, egg song, etc is fine but screaming is not.
Would the Welsummer fit well for our situation?
We already had to rehome a girl because she couldn't quit yelling at everyone and everything. (yes they get to free range when we are home).
Thanks for any insight.
I have both Wesummers and BCM's and while either would fit your requirements, Marans have more of a reputation for broodiness. Mine are still young and I have one broody Welsummer now, so my experience doesn't exactly match the reputations, but since I have 18 Welsummers and only 4 Marans, and the only hens over a year old are 3 of the Welsummers, I may see more broodiness in the Marans in the future.
I would still recommend the Welsummers the most. If you want dark eggs, seek out a breeder who can show you the eggs their stock lays. Commercial hatcheries won't do this, for good reason, you'd probably be unhappy and not buy their Welsummer chicks. My Welsummer and Marans eggs are identical, we have to mark them before they get put together, but there's no problem telling their eggs from the other breeds.