Okay, interesting. People around here just call everything that interacts with their live stock 'herding dogs', so that's probably my confusion.OK this will be many parts so here it goes. Yes, herding dogs shouldn't be with stock 24/7. It's actually a big pet peeve of mine, and a theme I've noticed quite frequently done. Herding dogs appear like a predator to the stock, and that's how they move the stock around. With controlled pressure. On the other hand, LGD's become part of the herd, and fight off predators. In addition, LGD's can effectively protect the stock against predators, something that herding dogs are not equipped to do