Yes, he does. Wish he was a bit heavier in body type. Since I process all the extra boys and older hens, dual purpose is important, and the one 'extra' roo I kept last year (#8's dad) is far too slight - but he was just so good with the girls, I couldn't process him last year.
Anyways, I personally like the black one - but that is somewhat clouding my judgement, as he is too slight.
Either of the 2 nicer Cuckoo Marans really could be a keeper so far - the Red leakage one is generally friendlier/calmer but still watchful/alert.
If I take a step back and don't let emotions in, either the Red leakage or #1 should be the option -both have pros and cons.
Red leakage boy has the disposition and body type.
#1 Is also good with the girls, but not a personality of 'commander in chief' like the Marans boy. He is medium build, but, in theory, carries the blue egg coloring gene.
One of the big selling points of my eggs, other than being farm fresh & organic, is the variety of colors in a dozen. Light brown, dark brown, blue, green, olive, and, yes Aurora, even PINK! (until they are washed!)
So, I want to breed BRs, the others, I just want a variety of egg colors with decent layers (not high production) and a decent sized body for use when they are processed. My retirement plan is that I will get a special exemption license and process the extra roos & older hens and be able to sell them, plus a few pullets each year along with the eggs, so maybe they will actually pay for themselves or create a slight profit. (As opposed to now where I am working to support them!) I also want to create my own line of meat birds - like the red ranger type, not the cornish cross type. i.e. slower growth than the cornish, but still decent size - yet also able to act like chickens and have a decent life until that fateful day.

(Note, neither of these boys would be used for the meat bird line, I don't think -if I keep the marans boy, we will see how he fills out. But, I plan on using a DC boy.)