I'm sorry you did not have a good experience with your Marans. I have loved every single one of mine. I wonder if could be a "Cuckoo" thing?When we got our clean-legged Cuckoo Marans in 2012 she was a mated bird as her missing back feathers indicated the tell-tale matings. So her 1st 5 eggs we thought may be fertile & gave them to a neighbor's broody. 3 eggs hatched & a couple of them grew out Cuckoo males w/feathered legs ~ a clean-legged Cuckoo momma that had feather-legged Cuckoo offspring? Our Cuckoo Marans hen layed dark brown eggs which were pretty but never the deep chocolate one expects from a Marans. If she got anywhere near a #3 on the Marans egg chart it was rare ~ they were mostly #2 & rarely #3. For those #2 & #3 Cuckoo eggs we could've got Welsummers instead w/ terra cotta speckled eggs & a better temperament than a Cuckoo Marans. But that's just me thinking back again...
Marans egg chart
View attachment 4061885
Welsummer hens look like Light Brown Leghorns but Wellies have the unique speckled terra cotta eggs
![]()
I have only had Black Copper Marans. Lovely hens and wonderful stunning roosters. My dad is a hard one to impress and my boys definitely impressed him. He tells everyone for such large roosters he has never met more calm and gentle boys.
In my original 6 Marans I ended up with 4 boys and 2 girls. I kept my favorite boy Drumstick and both girls. Holly who is my last original marans who was the french type and her sister Daisy who was the brittish type with clean legs. Temperaments were the same but egg color was vastly different. Holly and her offspring have all laid darker solid colored eggs. Daisy and her offspring lay the heavily speckled eggs. Daisy's line had the best hackle markings of the hens. They still are not perfect but I wanted feathered legs and good hackle markings with those heavily speckled eggs. I finally got that in Daisy's great-granddaughter Lilly. I swear Lilly is Daisy reincarnated with feathered legs. She is as big as Daisy was, lays gorgeous eggs and like Daisy her eggs are rare. Oh she is laying all right, she just likes to hide them most of the time. I am really tempted to throw her in with the silkie breeding pen this year to break that egg hiding habit she has.
Lilly's egg