I think a collar is a better choice than a harness, even if your dog jumps against it. If it hurts her, she will probably stop jumping. A 1.5-2inch collar with a metal buckle probably would be best. I have to tie my dogs out too, and my lab's got a collar around that measurement. I think it's better when the collar is wider, so it doesn't dig into the dog's neck too much.
I had the same issues, either they'd snap the collar or slip out of the harness. I solved the problem using a prong collar. They can't choke themselves, and it's self correcting. My dogs never lung out on the prongs which means they don't hurt themselves.
I know some people don't like prong collars, but they are a very effective tool, especially for a hard dog. And most boarder collies can be pretty hard. I would work with the dog on the collar and tie out for a few days before leaving the dog unattended for short periods. I only put the prong on my dogs when I let them out to go in the mornings, it's dark and I can't afford for them to take off or get skunked before work! UGH!
If all else false, I'd choose a prong over allowing my dog to hurt itself eating from the burn pile. The next step of course is a fence when you can install one.
if the problem is what the dog eats, on the burn pile, how about a muzzle, that way it could still run but not kill its self on the rubbish, (I dont like muzzles myself)
Quote:
To the OP. Can you purchase one of the chain link dog kennels sold by TSC, for example? Chaining a dog isn't really the best idea. Please do not ever, ever chain a dog with a "choke" or a prong collar on. A dog kennel is far more humane. You may need to cover it and shore up the bottom against digging for a determined dog. If you must chain, use a wide buckle collar.
Maybe you could invest in a sturdy tie-out stake ($15-$25) and a 10-15foot medium weight chain or cable ($10-$25). You might also consider a pulley line hooked up between two trees. I wouldn't leave a dog out too long--at most an hour at a time. Also, I would place the tie-out location in a quiet spot, preferably out of the action (neighbors, cars, neighborhood pets, etc.)
We originally bought a 10x10 kennel ($200) for our dogs to spend time in since we don't have a fenced yard, but it didn't work. One of our dogs dug out, and the other took the chain link and pulled it IN, weakening the entire kennel. There are better quality kennels out there (not made from basic chainlink) but they will be $400-$800.
Extremely active dogs will either need a heavy-duty kennel or an indestructible tie out system.
Remember, your average kennel is 100sqft. a 10 ft chain would give a dog 3x as much space.
I put my dog tied out 3-4 times a day, and leave her out at most 30minutes--she's usually done by then. But you will have to exercise your dog as well.
Quote:
To the OP. Can you purchase one of the chain link dog kennels sold by TSC, for example? Chaining a dog isn't really the best idea. Please do not ever, ever chain a dog with a "choke" or a prong collar on. A dog kennel is far more humane. You may need to cover it and shore up the bottom against digging for a determined dog. If you must chain, use a wide buckle collar.
Even with a wide collar, any dog that lunges hard on the tie out can cause injury to their necks. Correcting the lunging behavior will stop risk of injury.
I agree that chaining out isn't the best idea for sure. I'd never use a choke either. A Prong is not a choke collar. It pinches the skin, but cannot choke. I don't like doing it with my dogs, they actually have nice outside runs, but they won't "go" in them and have to be let out in the yard to go. I recently almost lost one of my dogs because he took off after deer. So for the dogs safety, I have no choice but to tie mine out for a minute so they can do their business and come back in. When I can be with them in the yard I don't chain them.