I have a drake that hates me and only me but he's a good drake to the hen, so I put up with him. What does this rooster mean to the flock? I think that's what you use to decide. If I was evaluating on me I would smoke that turd. But my guy is so gentle with his hen that I keep him around. That's a quality hard to find and worth a few blood blisters. I don't get near him without a broom or some kind of protection device and I have tried pinning him, carrying him, holding his bill, etc, etc, he hates me. But for the good of the flock....