As long as the shell is hard I would not worry about a rough texture. She is just adding a bit of extra calcium. I have set and hatched out rough eggs no problem.Yes I am also not worried about the cold weather, Henny raised chicks hatched end of Oct a couple yrs ago, and that Nov was brutally cold, one of the coldest winters in years in fact. My worry is as always getting Roos. Chicks are tougher than we give them credit.
I will think on the Marty thing. I don’t have to use curly and fluffy eggs, I can throw 3 Marty eggs under her, I could likely throw in all the four I have from Marty. My only concern is the quality of Marty’s eggs, lately they have been odd long eggs, and a funny shell, it’s strong enough but rough textured.
And a frizzle Polish cross pullet like Floyd would be real cute, so of course a Curly egg has to be used….. Curly’s a splash like P so guess it would be splash…. Oh the dilemma of it all.
Think I will just sit on my lawn chair here and mull it all over.I have a few days I don’t have to set Penelope’s egg right away…