Roo worry.
As I ponder the fate of little Chippy I looked up the standards for a Speckled Suspect Rooster. Meyer hatchery lists 9lb for a mature roo. OMG!!!
That is huge. Piglet weighs 3lb sopping wet! Actually I need to weigh her once she is done molting.
I know any rooster can injure any hen and it is all about how rough he is, and we hope he will be schooled by Tassels and Calypso who are decent sized hens, but does anyone think a 3X weight differential might be too much even if he is well mannered?
I am worried about poor Piglet and Pooh and not getting them stressed or injured and I think Cookie might end up the same sort of size as Piglet.
View attachment 4219530
So, I have varied thoughts on this. First - you need to see just how big he does get. I have found that frequently the size for large breeds posted is NOT the weight they actually are. For example:
Meyer Hatchery lists Barred plymouth rock Female avg. weight as 7.5 lbs, and male average weight as 9.5 lbs.
Well, let me tell you - that may be true for HERITAGE BPRs, but it is NOT the actual weights of my many, many BRs from Meyer. My heaviest girl was maybe 7 lbs, my heaviest roo was maybe 8.5 lbs. The girls were really closer to 5 lbs, the boys closer to 7 for the hatchery 'staple' BRs.
Now, my heritage BRs (that I got from somewhere else) ARE truly that weight.
So, 1st take away: don't worry about the listed weight - see what he REALLY ends up being
2nd: Roos of the same breed ARE bigger than the hens. Some difference is just fine.
3rd: Observe behavior. It may be that the two small girls never warm up to him.
4th: If he is gentile, and they are willing...I've seen a smaller girl not just 'crouch', but essentially be flat on the ground -but in crouched form - inviting a bigger roo to mate...and she never seemed to have an issue. The roo was gentile, and again, she was willing - and clearly knew he was a big boy & prepared for that!
The trouble comes from him NOT being gentile, and/or her not wanting his attentions. I
suspect that the weight difference will not be what you are imagining it to be......but, if it does end up being 3lbs to 9lbs, that is too big of a difference. Again, if he is good and they aren't willing (might not be if he is that heavy), it might all just work out okay anyways - as he will still have a number of bigger girls that will, hopefully, accept him.
Start with weighing your 2 smaller girls. Might also weigh geronimo and (? new name,
@RC?) now to get an idea of size/weight difference of your larger girl and 'him'.