I am bopping around when I have time, and also searching for information about breeders and hatcheries, and saw this again. I am thinking about a few more Buckeyes this year, and since Hazel is the only one of four Buckeyes from My Pet Chicken hatched in 2020 still alive, I was thinking I would not use MPC again, that the genetics were fairly bad for longevity. Also, the coloring on Butters and Popcorn was quite a bit lighter than I've seen SOP pictures, though that's much less important than their personalities, which were outstanding.
But what you're saying here is that the Buckeyes MPC gets and what gets shipped out from year to year might be from entirely different breeders or hatcheries, so you can't really tell? It's not a TSC = always Hoovers (or whoever it is they use) situation?