I want to see what Aster will look like when she is about 1 1/2 years old. I know right now she is slender and looking un-orpingtonish.She is her own lady for sure!
It is her face, leg color and now egg color that still sways me in that direction. Now, I know she is slender, and not looking like a orp.
Let me give you Siri.
Siri is a orp, but I would consider her a outlier for the breed. Siri is petite and she may weigh 4 pounds when she is soaking wet. My speckled sussex are bigger then she is. Her first year she was very slender, she did not widen through her chest and back until she was over a year old. Siri's siblings who I lost to the coyote about the time I lost Butter were 3 times her size. They were the traditional big broad fluffy orps you think of. I picked her out as a couple days old chick along with her siblings from Rural king. At that age I would not have thought she would be smaller, she was the same size as her siblings. She never gave any clue she would be different until about 2 to 3 months old. Then I had 2 giant girls and a tiny girl. Her eggs started out small as well and were the longest of the 3 to come up to normal orp size. She started laying around 6ish months old and she was closer to a year before she started laying larger eggs.
Again, I'm not saying Aster is for sure a orp, but, having siri and knowing what she is, not all orps become the big broad girls.