Hmm...just thinking out loud...List Holly & Jolly together so Jolly isn't placed cold turkey alone plus Holly might miss him & Georgie is her only closest relative. Mr P is so laid back Jolly (or Clyde) might be your stronger flock protectors in the long run? Silkie boys are incredible plus he's a non-frizzle for mating your frizzle girls. My ONLY regret about a Silkie roo is their crowing so I'm prohibited from keeping one

My Violet was never the same when we had to give Trumpet back. I don't know what was worse ~ seeing Trumpet's confusion taken away or Violet's loneliness figuring out which non-Silkie hen to pair up with ~ we had to get another same age Silkie pullet for her to pair up with. Silkies are a real stick-together kind of breed.
Violet & Trumpet
View attachment 4112129
View attachment 4112130
Violet w/ a new pullet "Mini" ~ it wasn't a close bond like w/ Trumpet but Violet & Mini were always toodling together~ it's been a Silkie thing for us to note over the yrs.
View attachment 4112135