This is a very helpful perspective for me.It is a very fraught topic, one that we must come to terms with by ourselves as there's no legislation anywhere (as far as I can tell).
I'm very troubled by so-called "waste" cockerels.
As someone who is obliged to ensure my neighbours are not disturbed by noise, I keep hens. My four hens had four brothers.
I have no idea what happened to those brothers. Ground up alive? Heads chopped off? Necks snapped? Roosters?
Terrified and panicked?
Calm and peaceful?
I haven't a clue.
So, my approach in future will be hatch my own and do my own disposals.
First, I'll try rehoming, but I genuinely think most people who accept cockerels eat them, so it might be impossible to find a home where they can live out their days in peace. Second, if I can't find an acceptable home, they will be humanely put to sleep by the vet.
This way the cockerels will live the healthiest and happiest lives I can possibly provide, eventually being rehomed or put to sleep.
My reasons are (1) it puts the responsibility for the brothers of my hens into my own hands and therefore I am able to take up the most ethical stance possible, (2) that step alone takes me out of the market for pullets and relieves other people of killing my hens brothers (2) like every other sentient being, the cockerels won't have any clue of life expectancy, they'll live joyfully in the moment until they must go (3) perhaps they can live their lives out in homes where they will be valued (4) if not, the end will be free of pain and panic.
It took me a long time to construct this stance. But for me, it's the right one.
Thank you.
I think I will ask my farm couple what they do with the cockerels. I am 90% sure they get eaten but I may be OK with that if they are humanely dispatched and raised in good conditions up to that point.