I don’t have experience with any of those listed (I used My Pet Chicken). Just piping in to say the closest to you by mail would be a good factor to include. Go to your local PO office now and make friends. Ask them how it’s been going with the mail and what they expect and ask for a frank and honest answer. There’s been plenty of horror stories, including on this thread.I'm getting close to ordering chicks by mail. I've never done this before.
Sooo... if you were choosing among hatcheries... who would you order from? I really want Bielefelders, so that is the first criteria. If you have ordered from any of these places, what was your experience, and would you order from them again?
Cackle
Murray Mc Murray
Mt Healthy
Other...?
Thank you.... getting chick fever here, can you tell?

If you are satisfied, ask them what they normally do and what they’d like you to do. Mine was a very small office, being rural here too they handle lots of chicks, they had my number and they called me very early as soon as the chicks came in (7:30am). There was no hitch in the mail, they got here fast, and I feel lucky it went smoothly.